OWS Basic Info

Daily OWS News

Photobucket

Photobucket

We are....
~ firefly-dreaming
a virtual home to learn (or teach!) alternative methods of solving problems we find facing us each day. By sharing ideas & knowledge on living with less stress, more joy & embracing tolerance & compassion we are working towards building a sustainable future for all living beings.


please if you can...
help us glow brightly!

~OR~ if you'd prefer

Payment Options
Remember, you can always



Facebook

Do it DAILY!
Photobucket
Just a few seconds of your time can make a BIG difference
in someone's life....


PhotobucketPhotobucket

be sure to click on ALL the top tabs at Click2Give!
Photobucket

be sure to click on ALL the side tabs at Care2!
Photobucket

Photobucket

Fight World Hunger






Brighter Planet's 350 Challenge

The Small Is Beautiful Manifesto

Photobucket

Greenpeace


I Support WWF





BOOK NOOK: Italian Shoes by Henning Mankell (October, 2010)

  

by: Xanthe

Tue Mar 29, 2011 at 06:51:16 AM EDT


(2pm~
- promoted by RiaD
)

Okay, finally a new book.  I did think about reviewing The Dollmaker by Hariette Arnow or Grapes of Wrath by Steinbeck, but don't know if I have the clarity and distance to write about these books now.  I am living in the roil - too close to write of either tough but heartbreaking novel.

Mankell is known for his Swedish detective series:  Kurt Wallender.  Though not a mystery, there is actually a similarity between Kurt and Fredrik.  A dark etiolated energy of muddled sadness.  

A word about the physicality of books, often overlooked by readers.  The author structures the book like a symphony.  It reads:  First Movement Ice; Second Movement: The Forest; Third Movement: The Sea; and Fourth Movement: Winter Solstice.  Thus on the cover page, he sets up his novel.  I equate these "movements" with the Germanic fairy tales of the Grimm Brothers, the Icelandic Sagas and Tales of Hans Christian Anderson, with a hint of Beowulf. (Don't take a class where you have to read Beowulf, says Woody Allen in Annie Hall.  For sure - one could tailor that remark to a book review.)

ICE:

Fredrik Welin, a retired, successful surgeon, has isolated himself to a Swedish island where his grandparents lived, and where he thought he would eventually make a "summer home."  He has lived here now for twelve years, alone with his dog and cat.  He is 66 at the novel's beginning, and his only visitor is Jansson the postman who flies onto the ice-locked island with his mail and provisions.  The landscape is stark, white, cold, lonely.  Each winter morning, Fredrik cuts a hole in the ice and dives in the icy water.  Why?  Well, that is for the reader to discern, though here are Fredrik's words:

Every day I jump down into my black hole in order to get the feeling that I am still alive.  Afterwards, it's as if my loneliness slowly fades away....As my feet reach the bottom I can stand up in the water; I shan't disappear under the ice....I am again amazed by what happened to my life.  I made a mistake.  And I refused to accept the consequences.
   
Xanthe :: BOOK NOOK: Italian Shoes by Henning Mankell (October, 2010)
Into this meager, bleak landscape, one morning Fredrik sees a figure out on the ice.  It is a woman with a walker.  Jansson must have dropped her off.  The woman is a lover from his youth, Harriet.  He abandoned her when he came to America to do postgraduate work years ago.  She falls over on the ice with her arms outstretched.  He puts her in a wheelbarrow and struggles to get her to the house.  Harriet is dying from cancer.  Years ago Fredrik promised  to take her to a forest pool where his father took him as a child.  She is now holding him to that promise.  Surprisingly, he acquiesces.

He will drive Harriet to a small town to pick up Harriet's daughter.  They will go on to the forest pool.  At the end of this section, they reach Louise's caravan outside town:

The caravan door opened.  A woman emerged.  She was wearing a pink dressing gown and high-heeled shoes...This is my daughter, said Harriet.  I stayed where I was.  This is your father, said Harriet to her daughter.  

This is the end of Ice.  I liken Ice to be a period of sleep, evil spells, imprisonment such as exists in the works of the Grimm Brothers - Sleeping Beauty, Snow White -- stasis.  There will be no more of imprisonment for Fredrik now - he can surface from the ice.  He is free to seek redemption.

THE FOREST

The three travelers take on the trip through the forest.  Harriet's illness intensifies; she is in great pain but they continue on. Fredrik says of the trip:

My whole life changed before my eyes.  I'd managed to get this far.  There might be a few crossroads yet to come.  But not too many.  My journey was nearly over. (In fact it is not.)

In fairy tales, a forest is always a dangerous place, full of treachery and dragons.  Italian Shoes is a classic journey of a hero who must face obstacles before he wins the prize.  These goals include his daughter's love, and a reproachment with Harriet.  There is another goal.  He must face his frozen life and why he lives it.  The reader now learns that years before Fredrik amputated the wrong, non-cancerous arm of a young woman, Agnes.  He left his home, his work and took up residence on the lonely, cold island.  Fredrik turned his back and abandoned himself.

Let's step back for a moment -- Fredrik is not a likeable character.  He is stiff necked, arrogant, cold.  He abandoned a woman who loved him and whom he loved.  Still, there is something in the character of a man who jumps into ice every morning to undertake a realized self-punishment that is remarkable.   Note, dear reader, that he reimprisons himself every morning by taking that icy odyssey.  It takes a great turn of fate to waken him.  Now it has come in the guise of family.

When he was a child, his waiter father told him a good pair of shoes would make him better able to do his work properly.  (An author chooses his title carefully.  Heed it.)  By the way, the daughter who is quirky and difficult herself, occasionally wears a pair of red high heels throughout the trip.  And she will take him to an Italian shoemaker where she lives who spends several hours properly fitting him for said shoes.

Now Fredrik is free to visit Agnes who is running a home for foster girls.  Agnes is living a life of purpose.  She has one arm, which has turned out to be noncancerous after all.  She tells him:

I used to be a swimmer....I could have become a champion.  I can say, without bitterness that my strong point was not my legs, but the strength I had in my arms.

Italian Shoes is a novel of movement and stasis.  Life is movement and stillness but it demands both to be properly lived.  The novel hints that Agnes and Fredrik will become friends, maybe lovers.  After all, they are a necessary line to each other's life.

The last few sentences of The Forest:

Standing alone out there on the pier, I started to cry.  Every single door inside me was swinging back and forth in the wind, which seemed to be getting stronger every time.

THE SEA

Come on - you knew this was coming.  Fredrik shoots his ailing dog. The cat disappears. And one of the foster girls visits the island and commits suicide.  His old life is falling away.  (I apologize to my readers to give just one sad line to the life of this girl - but this review cannot take on all that goes on in the novel.  Her story alone would make a fine novella.)  I offer here my tears to this girl and all like her.  (This is truly a Scandanavian novel!)

The beginning of April - Louise and Harriet (now close to death) visit the island.  There is a happy celebration with Jansson and the nearby town's doctor, wife and grandaughter.  In the midst of the joy of gathering, Louise talks about her boxing which she has undertaken because "people must fight for what is right in this life."  (Yes, it is an exhausting novel, but it is a good exhaustion.  I slept soundly after I finished it.)  Even Harriet now near the end enjoys the gathering. The travel is ending as these people move onto the sea -- and finally home - a hint of the Odyssey.  And Harriet dies.

WINTER SOLSTICE

Fredrik takes on a spaniel he rescued while on his forest journey, and Agnes visits the island.  She will bring her girls here, as she has lost the lease on her home.  His daughter also visits.  When his daughter leaves:

Now it was only the dog and me.  My friend Carra (He never named the prior dog or called him a friend!).  It's going to be just as quiet here as it always is for the time being.  Then we shall build a new house.  And girls will play music far too loudly, they'll be shouting and sometimes they will hate the island.  But they're coming here....A bunch of wild horses is on its way here.    

The denoument and a particularly beautiful passage. Simple, elegant, spare - like a winter's day.  And what moves freely as wild horses! Fredrik is in the midst of his Bergmanian redemption.

The shoes arrive from the old shoemaker -- a pair of black shoes with a hint of violet.

                                       ******

This is a splendid book.  I usually prefer a woman as protagonist and/or writer.  But here, Mankell has given us a man, flawed but capable of great courage. I am always willing to smooth a woman's flaws in novels - here I can forgive a man's. Fredrik is a man's man.  (Impolitic but it's how I feel.) Plus I love the structure as it relates to the old tales.  Read it.  It cleanses.

Well, dear reader, it is now almost 6 am.  I started writing this at about 4 am and had to reread some passages because I hadn't read it for a few weeks.  My gs seem to be stuck on this new keyboard - but I am off to my tempurpedic (in the spirit of Sweden) and will edit when I awaken from my slumber.  I love this book and have become quite fond of Fredrik.      

 


Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

- You can use Disqus, Google, Twitter, Facebook, Yahoo or OpenID accounts to comment

I hope you do read this book - (15.00 / 3)
It is impressive and while not an easy read - somehow there is a feeling of peace when done.  

For who could have foretold
That the heart grows old.
W.B. Yeats


this is (9.00 / 2)
far, far from the genres i usually read...
but it does sound very interesting. & one mrD would love.
i will tell him of this, have him read your revue

& thank you dear Xanthe
for broadening my horizons

"Indeed, if a poor man will spend a year in prison for stealing out of hunger,
how high would the gallows need to be to hang the rich man?"
~The Patrician in 'Snuff' by Terry Pratchett



this will (15.50 / 2)
front page at 2pm(eastern)
i've changed the time from 1 to 2pm for these....

"Indeed, if a poor man will spend a year in prison for stealing out of hunger,
how high would the gallows need to be to hang the rich man?"
~The Patrician in 'Snuff' by Terry Pratchett



Funny you should mention (14.50 / 2)
Swedish novelists: I just finished The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo yesterday.  It's a far cry from what you're describing here, of course, but quite compelling.

Thanks for the review.  I probably won't read it anytime soon (I doubt I could find it soon, unless I ordered it from Amazon) but will certainly keep an eye out for it.  It does sound amazing.

English usage is sometimes more than mere taste, judgment and education - sometimes it's sheer luck, like getting across the street.
E. B. White  


You're probably just being polite but it is (0.00 / 0)
a worthy read.  Try the library - if you like Girl - you may like this, not exciting - but compelling.  If you like Bergman films - you will like this.

thanks for reading, Youffraita.  

For who could have foretold
That the heart grows old.
W.B. Yeats


[ Parent ]

Photobucket



Since February 19, 2010


Need HELP setting up your website or blog? Have a site & want to give it more oomph?
Contact Edger at: edger10 {at} gmail {dot} com
Menu

If you would like to join us
you'll need an account

Please Click Here
to make one

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?




Follow DreamerFirefly on Twitter

Active Users
Currently 0 user(s) logged on.



Search




Advanced Search

moon phases

CURRENT MOON


Links to Enjoy

In The Spotlight

~Plutocracy Files~

Radical Radio
~Left-Wing Radio Stations~

~Political Discontent Radio~

Brilliant Blogs
~Antemedius
~Be-Think
~Burning the Midnight Oil
~Cabaretic
~Daily Kos
~DocuDharma
~The Dream Antilles
~dubious ventures
~Ethicurean
~fake consultant
~Firedoglake
~Hecate
~Ignoring Asia
~La Vida Locavore
~Lets Japan
~Margaret & Helen
~Minimalist Photography
~The Minimalist Woman
~Muskegon Critic
~My Left Wing
~New Progressive Alliance
~Original Cin's
~patricjuillet
~Pioneer Woman Cooks!
~Right of Assembly
~The Stars Hollow Gazette
~Street Prophets
~Timbuk3
~White Knuckles
~Wild Wild Left
~Wise Living Journal
~

~Fun Finds

~Good Places

~
Interesting~

~
Spiritual Sites

~
Ready Resources

~
Weather



Powered by: SoapBlox