OWS Basic Info

Daily OWS News

Photobucket

Photobucket

We are....
~ firefly-dreaming
a virtual home to learn (or teach!) alternative methods of solving problems we find facing us each day. By sharing ideas & knowledge on living with less stress, more joy & embracing tolerance & compassion we are working towards building a sustainable future for all living beings.


please if you can...
help us glow brightly!

~OR~ if you'd prefer

Payment Options
Remember, you can always



Facebook

advertisement

Do it DAILY!
Photobucket
Just a few seconds of your time can make a BIG difference
in someone's life....


PhotobucketPhotobucket

be sure to click on ALL the top tabs at Click2Give!
Photobucket

be sure to click on ALL the side tabs at Care2!
Photobucket

Photobucket

Fight World Hunger






Brighter Planet's 350 Challenge

The Small Is Beautiful Manifesto

Photobucket

Greenpeace


I Support WWF


Join me at http://www.350.org




Patriotism & the Refusal to Salute the Flag: A Rather Hot Debate:

  

by: mplo

Thu Apr 01, 2010 at 12:40:17 PM EDT


(4:30~ - promoted by RiaD)

Photobucket



Upon reading a rather interesting diary about flag-burning on another forum, I was reminded of an incident that took place in Randolph, MA, a town roughly 20 miles south of Boston. It began about 2 months before Ronald Reagan was re-elected to his second term as president, and the debate that took place over this particular incident continued well into the spring of that particular school year.
mplo :: Patriotism & the Refusal to Salute the Flag: A Rather Hot Debate:
A young high school senior who'd just turned 17 had stayed home from school starting on her birthday due to fears of physical harm for refusing to salute the flag during morning homeroom period.  When the high school senior brought in some information about constitutional rights vs. saluting the flag, her homeroom teacher then told her to "snap to it" and salute the flag like everybody else, which the girl refused to do, stating that "I like America, but I don't have to salute the flag in order to prove it."

Her homeroom teacher then told her that she was spitting on the flag, and asked if she would like it if someone spat on the Star of David.  The high school senior, who was Jewish, took offense to that remark, feeling that it was anti-Semitic.   The debate over the high school senior's refusal to salute the flag grew even fiercer and nastier.  For a few months, the girl's parents decided to keep her out of school until the school authorities would guarantee their daughter's safety.

The girl ended up losing friends at school, and nobody in school spoke to her, except to threaten to beat her up.  When the incident got into a local paper in that area of the state, people began calling the girl's family's house to leave nasty messages, some of which were virulently anti-semitic, although others called to wish the girl and her family well, and to wish them good luck.

Things got nasty enough so that the Justice Department even ended up getting involved:  when the high school senior finally returned to school later that fall, she was escorted to and from school every day by a member of the Justice Department, and she also ended up being escorted to and from all her classes.  Ultimately, that spring, the girl also skipped her Senior prom, and ended up dropping the charges against her homeroom teacher, after her homeroom teacher essentially issued an apology for the remark that she'd made in response to the girl's refusal to salute the flag.

Having said all of the above, there were at least a couple of things that made this story as interesting as it was.  First of all, the girl and her family were not leftwing liberals--not even liberals, but, in fact, were quite conservative.  Later, the girl admitted that "had she been old enough to vote, she would've gone for Ronald Reagan.", and that she admired the (late) Mier Kahane.  "I think he's great.  I like what he stands for and says."  Plus, she and her family really were quite patriotic, to boot.  Secondly, it was interesting that a kid that age had as much awareness as she had of the workings of the Constitution and constitutional rights and that she had the temerity to stand up for her rights.


Tags: (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

- You can use Disqus, Google, Twitter, Facebook, Yahoo or OpenID accounts to comment
mplo's Tip Jar: (8.00 / 6)


The more things change, the more they stay the same.

another great essay, Miki (8.00 / 6)
...that a kid that age had as much awareness as she had of the workings of the Constitution and constitutional rights and that she had the temerity to stand up for her rights.

¡brava! we need a nation of youth just like this

It's not what you look at that matters, it's what you see. ~ Thoreau ... and, do no harm


Thanks again, newpioneer! (8.00 / 5)
While I agree that a nation of youth like this is needed, our first Amendment rights need protection so that people like this won't be squashed, if one gets the drift.  However, as I pointed out in the thread, the other thing that made the story as interesting as it was is that this particular family was not liberal, but, in fact, quite conservative in their overall outlook and politics.  The young girl's admission that she "would've voted for Ronald Reagan had she been old enough to vote", and her admiration for the (late) Rabbi Meir Kahane says it all, and presents a very interesting perspective.

The more things change, the more they stay the same.

[ Parent ]
very interesting indeed! (8.00 / 5)
and for me it doesn't matter from what political spectrum one comes from, standing up for what you truly believe is what's important. as long as what you believe doesn't lead to actions that cause harm.  :O(

It's not what you look at that matters, it's what you see. ~ Thoreau ... and, do no harm

[ Parent ]
Absolutely spot-on, newpioneer! (8.00 / 5)
This:

it doesn't matter from what political spectrum one comes from, standing up for what you truly believe is what's important. as long as what you believe doesn't lead to actions that cause harm.  :O(

says it all, in a nutshell, newpioneer.

The more things change, the more they stay the same.


[ Parent ]
Very interesting story Miki (8.00 / 5)
what bravery it takes to stand on principle in the face of such opposition.

Bear Shake Tree Pictures, Images and Photos

this reminds me of the (8.00 / 4)
10 year old refuses to say pledge of allegiance story that came out last fall....

"Indeed, if a poor man will spend a year in prison for stealing out of hunger,
how high would the gallows need to be to hang the rich man?"
~The Patrician in 'Snuff' by Terry Pratchett




advertisement

Photobucket



Since February 19, 2010


Need HELP setting up your website or blog? Have a site & want to give it more oomph?
Contact Edger at: edger10 {at} gmail {dot} com
Menu

If you would like to join us
you'll need an account

Please Click Here
to make one

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Song of the...

~♥~


Updated Twice Daily
5 am & 5pm





Follow DreamerFirefly on Twitter

Active Users
Currently 1 user(s) logged on.



Search




Advanced Search

advertisement

moon phases

CURRENT MOON


Links to Enjoy

In The Spotlight

~Plutocracy Files~

Radical Radio
~Left-Wing Radio Stations~

~Political Discontent Radio~

Brilliant Blogs
~Antemedius
~Be-Think
~Burning the Midnight Oil
~Cabaretic
~Daily Kos
~DocuDharma
~The Dream Antilles
~dubious ventures
~Ethicurean
~fake consultant
~Firedoglake
~Hecate
~Ignoring Asia
~La Vida Locavore
~Lets Japan
~Margaret & Helen
~Minimalist Photography
~The Minimalist Woman
~Muskegon Critic
~My Left Wing
~New Progressive Alliance
~Original Cin's
~patricjuillet
~Pioneer Woman Cooks!
~Right of Assembly
~The Stars Hollow Gazette
~Street Prophets
~Timbuk3
~White Knuckles
~Wild Wild Left
~Wise Living Journal
~

~Fun Finds

~Good Places

~
Interesting~

~
Spiritual Sites

~
Ready Resources

~
Weather



Powered by: SoapBlox